Trade Commodity Stocks, ETFs, or Futures Contracts?

Unfortunately, our propensity toward the familiar often holds us back and I feel this is even more true in regards to the world of trading. Despite the human tendency to gravitate to the norm, I would like to challenge your perception of the markets and the way you approach price speculation. Perhaps thinking outside of the box will lead you into alternative arenas and improve the efficiency of your trading ventures. Gold futures, or GLD ETF

The futures markets often get a "bad rap" by the investment community thanks to horror stories in regards to traders losing their house along with their shirt. However, losses are possible in any market. It doesn't seem fair to blame the trading venue, the blame might lie with the participants themselves. That said, there are certainly more temptations in the futures markets than in most other arenas.


If you are going to speculate, do it in the futures markets
I have found that equity traders are reluctant to use the futures markets as a trading vehicle. This is partly because it is more convenient to simply buy a commodity ETF with their stock broker, or their broker might even offer limited access to some futures contracts. Yet, choosing the familiar and convenient road, generally comes with the baggage of inefficiency. In short, ETFs don’t always follow the underlying asset, and stock brokers offering future trading on the side are typically ill equipped to provide proficient service to traders.

Another hesitancy stems from the fact that a futures contract isn't an asset; instead it is a liability. Specifically, despite the statistic that most speculators sell their obligation before the delivery process, a futures contract is actually an agreement to buy or sell a specific amount of a commodity or financial instrument at a particular price on a stipulated date in the future. To clarify, futures traders are not exchanging the commodity itself, just an agreement to exchange the commodity. Therefore, unlike equities, futures traders have no feeling of ownership.

I’m not convinced this is a valid argument. Let's face it...aside from a monthly brokerage statement that says so, many stock or ETF holders don't really own anything either; ask those holding shares of Lumber Liquidators. Shareholders are, in essence, guaranteed the future cash flows, if any, of that particular security but the benefits of ownership seem to end there.

There are some compelling reasons to look toward trading in the futures markets with a true commodity broker. I hope that you are able to open your mind to an unconventional but perhaps more efficient marketplace. We will focus on the most popular stock index futures contract, the e-mini S&P but the same principals can be applied to all commodities. For instance, a silver speculator could buy an ETF, buy a silver mining stock or they could streamline their efforts through the purchase of a silver futures contract.

Click here to continue reading about commodity speculation with futures contracts on

Futures and Options Trading Booksby Carley Garner

What People are Saying about Our Commodity Trading Books

Choosing a Futures Broker and Brokerage Service

Full-Service or Online Trading?

The decision to trade online or through a full-service commodity broker will undoubtedly make a large impact on your bottom line.

Learn More

A Fair Commission Rate vs. Low Commission

To look at commission rates objectively, we must understand the background of the futures industry and how brokerages accept risk for fees.

Learn More

Choosing a Commodity Brokerage Firm

Deciding on a commodity brokerage firm is a significant decision and shouldn’t be taken lightly. Not all traders and brokers are compatible.

Learn More

Choosing a Futures and Options Broker

Most traders in search of a futures broker are concerned primarily with trading platforms, commission, and quality guidance.

Learn More

The Truth about Futures Commission

The goal of futures trading should be to MAKE money, not SAVE it! Discount commodity brokers cut corners that cost their clients time & money.

Learn More

Commodities via Futures or ETFs?

A key difference to trading commodity futures over ETFs is leverage, but there is more to discuss, such as taxes, market hours, and efficiency.

Learn More